spacer image
spacer image

Welcome! You're looking at an archived Snarkmarket entry. We've got a fresh look—and more new ideas every day—on the front page.

May 7, 2004

<< 2004 National Mag Award Finalists | Go West >>

Our Latent Cruelty


If there’s one story I can’t imagine writing as a journalist, it’s this — the hounding-of-the-family-members-after-someone-commits-an-atrocity story:

In one image, Private England is clenching a cigarette between her teeth while giving a thumbs-up in front of naked Iraqi prisoners. In another that became public on Thursday, she is holding a leash attached to a naked prisoner’s neck.

The photographs have left her family and friends aghast and searching for answers. They are convinced that she would never have thought up anything so cruel on her own and that she must have been following orders.

Of course they are. Few families walk around suspecting their own of harboring despotic tendencies. What are they going to say? “That Lynndie. She always tortured insects and small mammals as a kid. I knew no good would come of it.”

Not a comforting thought, but we are all probably much more capable of atrocious behavior than we can imagine. Another article in today’s NYT recalls a 30-year-old study:

In 1971 researchers at Stanford University created a simulated prison in the basement of the campus psychology building. They randomly assigned 24 students to be either prison guards or prisoners for two weeks.

Within days the “guards” had become swaggering and sadistic, to the point of placing bags over the prisoners’ heads, forcing them to strip naked and encouraging them to perform sexual acts.

The landmark Stanford experiment and studies like it give insight into how ordinary people can, under the right circumstances, do horrible things including the mistreatment of prisoners at the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq.

What is the distance between “normal” and “monster”? Can anyone become a torturer?

The answer to that last question, the article suggests, is “yes.” We aren’t all secret sadists, quietly wanting to inflict pain on our neighbors, but removed from our current frame of reference, quite a number of us — we should probably assume all of us — would do the worst.

Scary. Good to know?

Posted May 7, 2004 at 8:07 | Comments (2) | Permasnark
File under: Society/Culture


Those people have been torturing us for years . i feel no remorse , and I believe they deserved what they got . These are not people , these are violent emotionless animals . They believe in killing others to promote peace and Islam . Besides , getting them naked and making fun of them is allot better than the alternative ( killing them ) .

Posted by: Jer_pritch on January 3, 2006 at 12:58 PM

Okay, now I'm really annoyed that my comments always seem to have to go through the censorship filter before posting...

spacer image
spacer image