spacer image
spacer image

Welcome! You're looking at an archived Snarkmarket entry. We've got a fresh look—and more new ideas every day—on the front page.

May 21, 2005

<< Mapping the Market | Serendipity >>

Long in the Tooth

sithposter.jpg

For the moment, The New York Times has put up an archive of coverage of the Star Wars films, from the first Vincent Canby review of A New Hope (May 26, 1977) to now. My favorite moment comes in Janet Maslin’s review of The Empire Strikes Back (written 25 years ago today!):

If George Lucas makes good on his promise to turn Star Wars into a parade of nine films and spend several years on the making of each of them, we may all be pretty long in the tooth before this story gets told.

Good Lord. Nine?! Sith was fun, but really … we’re quite sure Lucas is done with this now, right?

RELATED: The 1983 fan reactions to Return of the Jedi on USENET (via MeFi).

UPDATE: I clearly was not paying enough attention. The Washington Post has a much nicer archive. (Although they do need to do a better job of copy-editing the old articles.)

CAPSULE REVIEW: Everyone’s pretty much agreed that it’s a very fun film with awful dialogue, and I’m no different. Some would call it the apotheosis of epic; I’m going to stick with fun film. While I’m impressed by the scope of Lucas’ story and how well it tied together, the writing and acting pretty much disqualifies this from the category of great cinema. It’s a wonderful spectacle, though.

mthompson-sig.gif
Posted May 21, 2005 at 10:23 | Comments (2) | Permasnark
File under: Movies

Comments

Eh... I didn't even think it was that much fun. The last twenty minutes -- and some of the interplay between Obi-Wan and Anakin -- was great, if only b/c it evoked so much of what will come next. But everything else... meh. Even Lucas's big special effects scenes don't really do it for me anymore. And the PACING was just so funky. Weird pauses... slow dialogue... odd cuts back and forth.

Addendum. Sometimes I enjoy a good cinematic reamage. Brad Plumer obliges with this defense of Episode II. (I know! It's crazy!)

spacer image
spacer image