Wow. Re-used animations in Disney movies, intercut to make the duplication clear. I can’t tell if it was corner-cutting or homage. Maybe a bit of both? (Via things.)
From what I know about animation, I’d say it’s mostly corner-cutting and a maybe a little bit homage. Some of these scenes were directed in a way that would allow the reuse of old animation in order to save time & money.
Yeah, I agree. In particular, you see a few scenes in these late Disney movies that reuse the same animation within the same film. Nothing homage-y about that.
Could it also be a way of creating consistent character markers? The characters (say, Maid Marion & Snow White) share certain traits (graciousness, sweetness, innocent joy) and the scenes are not dissimilar. (I don’t actually recognize all these movies, so I might be over extrapolating.) When you don’t have a human being who’s consciously inhabiting a character with a lifetime of body tics and mannerisms, *especially in dance*, capturing and repeating gesture might be a short cut-not quite the same as cost-cutting.
I say this as a dormant dancer in a tradition that relies heavily on repetitive use of signature gestures to demarcate rapid changes of character. It makes sense that once you had moody gestures mastered for your character in one scene, you’d want to repeat those motions in another.
Totally! While I have the sinking feeling that Tim & Bryan are right, and it’s just repetition for economy’s sake, I want it to be the kind of symbolism you’re talking about, Saheli.
I think of manga and anime, and all the expressive codes they use — lots of repeated imagery & motion. (Although, er, I guess a lot of that was for economy’s sake, too.)
I’m an animator and I can assure you it’s strictly cost-cutting. Re-use (showing the same scene again, with no changes) or cycles (repeating a series of drawings in a loop) are similar ways to shave expenses.
They wouldn’t do this at Pixar, but I work in television and we have a library of stock animation we can borrow from which is accumulated throughout a season of each show. Sometimes it makes sense to not reinvent the wheel.
Below, you can use basic HTML tags and/or Markdown syntax.
Composing a reply. Cancel?
Founded in 2003, Snarkmarket is a long-running conversation about media, journalism, technology, cities, design, books, music, movies, the future, and the past.
The title, it should be said, is a misnomer. You’ll see.
Follow along: @Snarkmarket on Twitter / Snarkmarket RSS
A leaky rocketship
/ Bless the toolmakers
/ The art of working in public
/ The cave, the corps, the league
/ The two mayors
/ Age of majority
/ A hypothetical path to the speakularity
/ Kanye west, media cyborg
/ Only crash
/ Stock and flow
All-time best comment threads:
Explosions in the sky
The deep snarkives: 2017 (1)