Jonah Lehrer tickles my brain-bone:
This reminds me of that great William James quote: “We ought,” he wrote, “to say a feeling of and, a feeling of if, a feeling of but, and a feeling of by, quite as readily as we say a feeling of blue, or a feeling of cold.” What is James talking about? He’s pointing out that language creates the illusion of transparency. We pretend that we’re just describing the “substantive parts” of the world – those nouns we match together with adjective and verbs in neat sentences – but this substance is inevitably shaded by “transitive” mental processes we aren’t aware of, such as gendered nouns and quirks of grammar. In other words, language is a constraint on thought, a concrete riverbed for the stream of consciousness.
One comment
I know this isn’t exactly the same thing, but it made my similarly-tickled brain bone resonate a little: NYT story about ‘character consolidation’ on Chinese ID cards.
Language as riverbed; language as rule-set; language as fabric of space-time!